Academic Notes for MBA Students COST AND MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING (Unit 2)
12. Cost-Volume-Profit (CVP) Analysis
12.1 Introduction to CVP Analysis
Cost-Volume-Profit Analysis is a powerful management tool that examines the relationship between costs, volume of activity, and profit. It helps managers understand how changes in volume affect costs and profits, enabling better planning and decision-making.
CVP analysis is based on several key assumptions:
- All costs can be classified as either fixed or variable
- Variable costs remain constant per unit
- Fixed costs remain constant in total within the relevant range
- Selling price per unit remains constant
- Production equals sales (no inventory changes)
12.2 Marginal Cost
Marginal cost represents the additional cost incurred to produce one additional unit of output. In the context of CVP analysis, marginal cost typically refers to variable cost per unit, as fixed costs do not change with production volume in the short run.
Formula: Marginal Cost = Variable Cost per Unit
Components of Marginal Cost:
- Direct materials per unit
- Direct labor per unit
- Variable manufacturing overhead per unit
- Variable selling and administrative expenses per unit
Example: If a company's variable costs include:
- Direct materials: $15 per unit
- Direct labor: $10 per unit
- Variable overhead: $5 per unit
- Variable selling expenses: $3 per unit
Then Marginal Cost = $15 + $10 + $5 + $3 = $33 per unit
12.3 Contribution per Unit and Total Contribution
Contribution per Unit is the amount remaining from each unit's selling price after covering variable costs. It represents the contribution each unit makes toward covering fixed costs and generating profit.
Formula: Contribution per Unit = Selling Price per Unit - Variable Cost per Unit
Total Contribution is the aggregate contribution from all units sold during a period.
Formula: Total Contribution = Contribution per Unit × Number of Units Sold or Total Contribution = Total Sales Revenue - Total Variable Costs
Example:
- Selling price per unit: $50
- Variable cost per unit: $30
- Units sold: 1,000 units
Contribution per Unit = $50 - $30 = $20 Total Contribution = $20 × 1,000 = $20,000
12.4 Profit-Volume Ratio (P/V Ratio)
The Profit-Volume Ratio, also known as the Contribution-Sales Ratio, expresses contribution as a percentage of sales revenue. It indicates what percentage of each sales dollar contributes to covering fixed costs and profit.
Formula: P/V Ratio = (Contribution per Unit ÷ Selling Price per Unit) × 100 or P/V Ratio = (Total Contribution ÷ Total Sales) × 100
Uses of P/V Ratio:
- Calculating break-even point in sales value
- Determining the impact of sales changes on profit
- Comparing profitability of different products
- Making pricing decisions
Example: Using the previous example: P/V Ratio = ($20 ÷ $50) × 100 = 40%
This means 40% of each sales dollar contributes to fixed costs and profit.
12.5 Break-Even Point
The break-even point is the level of sales at which total revenues equal total costs, resulting in zero profit or loss. It represents the minimum sales level required to avoid losses.
Break-Even Point in Units: Break-Even Point (Units) = Fixed Costs ÷ Contribution per Unit
Break-Even Point in Sales Value: Break-Even Point (Sales) = Fixed Costs ÷ P/V Ratio
Example:
- Fixed costs: $40,000
- Contribution per unit: $20
- P/V Ratio: 40%
Break-Even Point (Units) = $40,000 ÷ $20 = 2,000 units Break-Even Point (Sales) = $40,000 ÷ 0.40 = $100,000
12.6 Margin of Safety
Margin of Safety represents the excess of actual or budgeted sales over break-even sales. It indicates how much sales can decline before the company starts incurring losses.
Formulas: Margin of Safety (Units) = Actual Sales (Units) - Break-Even Sales (Units) Margin of Safety (Amount) = Actual Sales (Amount) - Break-Even Sales (Amount) Margin of Safety (%) = (Margin of Safety ÷ Actual Sales) × 100
Example:
- Actual sales: 3,000 units
- Break-even sales: 2,000 units
- Selling price: $50 per unit
Margin of Safety (Units) = 3,000 - 2,000 = 1,000 units Margin of Safety (Amount) = 1,000 × $50 = $50,000 Margin of Safety (%) = ($50,000 ÷ $150,000) × 100 = 33.33%
13. Decision Making in Management Accounting
Management accounting provides crucial information for various business decisions. Understanding these decision-making scenarios helps managers choose alternatives that maximize organizational value.
13.1 Key Factor Analysis
A key factor (or limiting factor) is a resource that limits an organization's ability to achieve higher levels of performance. Common limiting factors include:
- Production capacity (machine hours, labor hours)
- Raw material availability
- Market demand
- Financial resources
- Skilled labor shortage
Decision Rule for Key Factor: When faced with a limiting factor, prioritize products or activities that provide the highest contribution per unit of the limiting factor.
Formula: Contribution per Unit of Key Factor = Contribution per Unit ÷ Key Factor Required per Unit
Example: Two products with the following data, where machine hours are limited:
| Product | Contribution per Unit | Machine Hours per Unit | Contribution per Machine Hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | $30 | 3 hours | $10 |
| B | $25 | 2 hours | $12.50 |
Product B should be prioritized as it generates higher contribution per machine hour.
13.2 Pricing Decisions
Management accounting supports various pricing strategies through cost analysis and contribution margin calculations.
Cost-Plus Pricing: Price = Total Cost per Unit + Desired Profit Margin
Target Pricing: Determine the maximum cost that allows desired profit at market price.
Marginal Cost Pricing: Price = Variable Cost per Unit + Contribution toward Fixed Costs and Profit
Considerations in Pricing:
- Market conditions and competition
- Product life cycle stage
- Customer price sensitivity
- Cost structure and capacity utilization
- Strategic objectives
13.3 Product Profitability Analysis
Product profitability analysis helps identify which products contribute most to organizational success.
Steps in Product Profitability Analysis:
- Calculate contribution margin for each product
- Analyze contribution per unit of limiting factor
- Consider allocated fixed costs where relevant
- Evaluate strategic importance beyond financial metrics
- Consider cross-selling and complementary effects
Decision Criteria:
- Products with positive contribution margins should generally be continued
- Products with negative contribution margins should be evaluated for discontinuation
- Consider long-term strategic value and market positioning
13.4 Dropping a Product Line
The decision to discontinue a product line requires careful analysis of incremental revenues and costs.
Analysis Framework:
- Identify Avoidable Costs: Costs that will be eliminated if the product is dropped
- Consider Opportunity Costs: Alternative uses for released resources
- Evaluate Impact on Other Products: Complementary or substitute effects
- Assess Strategic Implications: Market position and customer relationships
Decision Rule: Drop the product line if: Lost Contribution < Avoidable Fixed Costs + Opportunity Benefits
Example: Product line data:
- Sales revenue: $100,000
- Variable costs: $60,000
- Contribution margin: $40,000
- Avoidable fixed costs if dropped: $45,000
Decision: Continue the product line since contribution ($40,000) covers most of the avoidable fixed costs ($45,000), and the shortfall is only $5,000.
13.5 Make or Buy Decisions
Organizations often face decisions about whether to manufacture components internally or purchase them from external suppliers.
Factors to Consider:
- Relevant costs of making vs. buying
- Quality considerations
- Reliability of supply
- Capacity utilization
- Strategic importance
- Long-term relationships
Analysis Framework:
- Calculate incremental cost of making internally
- Compare with purchase price from supplier
- Consider qualitative factors
- Evaluate capacity implications
Decision Rule: Make internally if: Incremental Cost of Making < Purchase Price + Associated Buying Costs
Example:
- Purchase price from supplier: $15 per unit
- Internal manufacturing costs:
- Direct materials: $6
- Direct labor: $4
- Variable overhead: $3
- Additional fixed costs: $1
- Total internal cost: $14 per unit
Decision: Make internally as it costs $1 less per unit than buying.
13.6 Export Order Decisions
When considering special export orders, managers must analyze incremental revenues and costs.
Key Considerations:
- Incremental revenue from export order
- Incremental costs (production, shipping, documentation)
- Available capacity
- Impact on domestic sales
- Currency exchange risks
- Political and economic risks
Decision Rule: Accept export order if: Incremental Revenue > Incremental Costs
Analysis Steps:
- Calculate contribution margin from export order
- Identify additional costs (export documentation, shipping, insurance)
- Consider capacity constraints
- Evaluate impact on existing customers
- Assess strategic value of entering export markets
13.7 Sell or Process Further
This decision involves determining whether to sell products at an intermediate stage or process them further for higher selling prices.
Analysis Framework:
- Identify Additional Processing Costs: Incremental costs beyond the split-off point
- Calculate Incremental Revenue: Additional revenue from further processing
- Compare Incremental Revenue with Incremental Costs
- Consider Market Conditions: Demand for intermediate vs. finished products
Decision Rule: Process further if: Incremental Revenue from Further Processing > Incremental Processing Costs
Example:
- Selling price at split-off point: $20 per unit
- Selling price after further processing: $30 per unit
- Additional processing costs: $8 per unit
Incremental revenue = $30 - $20 = $10 per unit Incremental cost = $8 per unit Net benefit = $10 - $8 = $2 per unit
Decision: Process the product further as it generates additional profit of $2 per unit.
13.8 Shut Down vs. Continue Operations
Organizations facing losses must decide whether to continue operations or temporarily shut down.
Short-term Decision Criteria: Continue operations if: Contribution Margin > Avoidable Fixed Costs
Long-term Decision Criteria: Continue operations if: Total Revenue > Total Avoidable Costs + Opportunity Costs
Factors to Consider:
- Customer relationships and market position
- Employee relations and rehiring costs
- Supplier relationships
- Fixed costs that continue during shutdown
- Restart costs when resuming operations
- Strategic importance of maintaining market presence
Example: Company facing losses with the following data:
- Revenue: $500,000
- Variable costs: $300,000
- Contribution margin: $200,000
- Fixed costs: $250,000
- Avoidable fixed costs if shut down: $180,000
Short-term decision: Continue operations since contribution margin ($200,000) exceeds avoidable fixed costs ($180,000) by $20,000.
14. Integrated Decision-Making Framework
14.1 Steps in Management Decision-Making
- Define the Problem: Clearly identify the decision to be made
- Identify Alternatives: List all feasible options
- Gather Relevant Information: Collect quantitative and qualitative data
- Analyze Alternatives: Apply appropriate analytical techniques
- Consider Qualitative Factors: Evaluate non-financial implications
- Make the Decision: Choose the best alternative based on analysis
- Implement and Monitor: Execute the decision and track results
14.2 Common Pitfalls in Decision-Making
- Including sunk costs in analysis
- Ignoring opportunity costs
- Focusing only on short-term financial impact
- Overlooking strategic implications
- Failing to consider capacity constraints
- Inadequate consideration of risk factors
Post a Comment